Why Chefs Say “Stop Adding Milk or Water”
-
Flavor dilution:
-
Adding milk, cream, or water can dilute the natural buttery, earthy flavor of the potatoes.
-
-
Texture control:
-
Too much liquid can make mashed potatoes gluey or runny.
-
Chefs prefer controlling creaminess using butter and potato starch rather than liquid.
-
Chef’s Method for Perfect Mashed Potatoes
Ingredients
-
2 pounds potatoes (Yukon Gold or Russet)
-
1/2–1 cup butter (use high-quality butter)
-
Salt, to taste
-
Optional: cream or half-and-half, added sparingly at the end
Instructions
-
Boil or steam potatoes until just tender.
-
Drain thoroughly—excess water makes them watery.
-
Mash while hot with butter first. The butter melts into the potatoes, creating richness without needing milk.
-
Add liquid sparingly:
-
If desired, add a splash of cream or warm milk only at the end for the exact texture you want.
-
-
Season well with salt (and pepper if you like).
Pro Tip
-
Steam potatoes instead of boiling: Less water absorption means creamier mashed potatoes naturally.
-
Use a potato ricer or food mill: Gives the smoothest texture without adding liquid.
-
Butter first, then liquid: Maximizes flavor and prevents gluey mash.
✅ Bottom line: Skip adding milk or water at the start—let the potato’s natural moisture and butter do the work. Only add liquid at the very end, and just enough for your preferred consistency.
If you want, I can give a chef-approved “ultra-creamy, buttery mashed potatoes” recipe that never needs milk and tastes restaurant-perfect.
Do you want me to do that?